The Pizzas Ask anyone that has been to Barnaby's and they will tell you that Barnaby's pizza is the best pizza in town and truely has a taste of its' own. In fact, when people compare pizzas in Tallahassee, they assume you mean you are comparing all the pizzas in town excluding Barnaby's, since it stands in a class by itself. We give you 40% more of the finest fresh ingredients, using the highest grades of mozzarella cheeses, fresh sausage and pizza dough mixed fresh daily. Of course, don't take our word for it, you will need to come by and try it for yourself. If you are not completely satisfied, please tell us and we will gladly refund your purchase price.